Yac Football

Back to home

2026 Fantasy Outlook

Justin Herbert

QB · Chargers

Chargers

QB9 ADP

QB9

ADP (57 ovr)

303.3

Proj Half-PPR

3,920 / 27 TD

Proj Pass

345 / 3 TD

Proj Rush

Herbert's 2025 was a delivery-system problem. The reputation says best arm in the league, and the deep tape backs it (95.4 PFF grade on 40-plus-yard throws since 2020, 3rd in the NFL), but his passing EPA was 16.1, 22nd among qualifiers, closer to Trevor Lawrence than to the top tier. The rushing covered for it: 498 yards on 83 carries at 6.0 a pop, an NFL-best 11.9 yards per scramble, except 439 of those 498 yards came on scrambles he was forced into, not runs anyone drew up. The reason is the line. The Chargers fielded the worst pass-blocking unit in football, Herbert took an NFL-high 54 sacks at a 43.9% pressure rate, and his game split clean (91.3 PFF, 0.30 EPA, 75th percentile) versus harassed (60.4 PFF, -0.55 EPA). Greg Roman ran the slowest-pace offense in the NFL on top of it, dropping Herbert to 29.6 attempts a game after three straight years above 39.

Roman is fired and Mike McDaniel runs the offense now, importing four of his Miami staffers to install it. The plan is on record: get the ball out in 2.4 seconds to take the rush out of the equation, while keeping the off-script gear intact. The overlap is real. Herbert ranked 2nd of 34 QBs in crossing and post accuracy in 2025 (17% over expected) and McDaniel's 2023 Dolphins led the league in crossing-route volume, and his 96.0 play-action grade (1st in 2024) feeds straight into the outside-zone boot game Tua's lack of mobility never allowed. The collision is timing. Herbert's EPA actually rises the longer he holds it, peaking at 4-plus seconds (0.20, 80th percentile), which is the inverse of what this scheme wants, and McDaniel is openly coaching the off-schedule habit out. Slater and Alt are both rehabbing toward camp and the interior got rebuilt, so whether the line holds is the season.

Weapons

Ladd McConkey

Bounce-back WR1, inherits Allen's vacated 122 targets

ALPHA

McConkey went 66/789/6 in a 2025 sophomore dip after an 82/1149/7 rookie year, on a cheap rookie deal. His 6-0/186, 4.39 profile and YAC/crosser game mirror Jaylen Waddle, the archetype McDaniel built around in Miami. His crossers cratered from 34 routes (9-of-9) in 2024 to 25 in 2025; with Keenan Allen's targets gone, he is the most direct volume beneficiary and the cleanest scheme fit in the room.

Quentin Johnston

Vertical WR2, team-leading TD rate, $18M 2027 option exercised

BOUNDARY-DEEP

Johnston went 51/735/8 and led Chargers WRs in TD rate, grading 89th percentile on go routes (32.5 aDOT). At 6-1/215 he is bigger than McDaniel's typical WR1 and his boom-bust deep diet is a stylistic mismatch with the underneath emphasis, but the exercised fifth-year option locks him into the boundary role for two seasons. He keeps two-high shells honest.

Tre Harris

X-receiver competition, rookie speed pressure behind him

DEPTH

Harris went 30/324 as a 2nd-round rookie on outside-only college tape, penciled as the X across from Johnston. The wrinkle is 4.26 R4 rookie Brenen Thompson, whose speed profile is closer to what McDaniel prefers in that role. Harris is in the vertical competition, not locked into it.

Keenan Allen

Returning slot tactician at 34, deep ball gone

BRIDGE

Allen came back on a 1yr/$8.5M deal as a third-down/slot option. He is still elite on timing routes over the middle (in/dig 98th percentile) but went 0-of-7 on go routes in 2025 — the vertical element is finished at 34. The front office signaled it is planning for life without him even with him on the roster.

Oronde Gadsden II

Jonnu Smith comp, freed to play receiver by Kolar add

MOVE-TE

Gadsden went 49/664/3 as a 5th-round rookie, a top-20 receiving TE by volume and efficiency. He profiles as a big-slot move TE rather than an in-line blocker, and the Chargers signed Charlie Kolar specifically to absorb blocking snaps in 21 personnel and free Gadsden as the detached F. That is the exact role that produced Smith's 88/884/8 under McDaniel in 2024.

Omarion Hampton

Bellcow RB with built-in receiving role

PASS-CATCH-RB

Hampton caught 32 balls as a rookie 1st-rounder and is the lead back, with speed-back Keaton Mitchell (4.37, 1st among 87 backs in explosive-run rate) added as the Achane-style space-game complement. The pass-catching back role McDaniel leans on is covered between them.

Protection

This is the load on Herbert's whole season. The 2025 line ranked dead last in run-blocking and 31st in pass-blocking, gave up the most pressures in the NFL, and let Herbert get sacked 54 times at a 43.9% pressure rate, 2nd-highest among high-volume QBs in the tracking era. It was triage: Rashawn Slater ruptured a patellar tendon in August, Joe Alt fractured an ankle after 6 games, and the Chargers were starting Austin Deculus and Bobby Hart by midseason. Herbert's PPG was 23.9 with Alt protecting him and 16.2 without. Both tackles are rehabbing ahead of schedule per the front office, the interior got rebuilt in free agency (Biadasz, Strange, re-signed Pipkins and Penning) and four more linemen were drafted, leaving four former first-rounders on the unit. The catch is zone-readiness: the guard spots are the weak link, with Penning carrying no zone experience and Alt mostly a gap blocker to date.

Playcall

McDaniel replaced Roman in January and chose the Chargers over the Bucs and Eagles HC openings, citing Herbert. His system is the Shanahan tree: NFL-leading pre-snap motion (74-86% in Miami versus LAC's 52% in 2025), a crosser/speed-dig passing tree, outside-zone runs, and a pivot from Roman's 67% three-WR looks toward 21-personnel-heavy sets. The new dimension is the ground game — McDaniel ran zero designed QB runs in Miami because Tua couldn't, and his Dolphins ranked 6th in RPO usage every year, so Herbert's mobility should expand both. Two risks travel with him: a documented third-quarter execution problem (Miami was outscored 113-27 in third quarters across 2025) and a short-yardage weakness (31 of 55 3rd/4th-and-1 runs failed in Miami) that runs into Hampton's power-back lead.

Scheme Fit

Crosser tree fits Herbert's best throws

Play-action plugs into outside-zone boots

Quick game targets the clean-pocket tier

Designed QB runs are a brand-new dimension

Timing collides with where his EPA peaks

Two-high shells are the known McDaniel counter

Key Variables

Do Slater and Alt stay healthy at tackle? The 0.85 EPA clean-vs-pressure gap and the 23.9-vs-16.2 PPG split with and without Alt make tackle availability the dominant swing on the entire 2026 outcome.
Does the rushing floor survive the scheme? 88% of Herbert's 498 rush yards were scramble-driven; the quick game suppresses scrambles, so designed QB runs and RPOs have to replace that volume for the floor to hold.
Can the release shrink toward 2.4s without losing the off-script gear? McDaniel is drilling an earlier release with weighted-ball footwork work; Tua operated at 2.35-2.43s in this system versus Herbert's 2.93s.
Does pace and volume recover? The slowest-pace offense cut Herbert to 29.6 attempts a game; McDaniel's Dolphins ran 65-plus plays, and a 3-4 play bump alone adds 1-2 FPPG.

Fantasy Range

Bull

QB1

Healthy line restores the clean pocket, the crosser and play-action tree lands, and pace recovery pushes volume to the MVP-tier outcome the +1000 odds are pricing.

Base

QB8

Scheme bump roughly offsets rushing-floor regression for a steady weekly QB1 with rushing upside, matching the FantasyPros ECR.

Bear

QB13

The line relapses and the quick game kills the scramble volume at the same time, leaving below-average passing efficiency exposed.

Health

Herbert has missed exactly one game in six seasons, but the availability hides a specific pattern. He has played through a 2021 hand issue, 2022 rib cartilage and a January 2023 labrum surgery, a 2023 left middle finger fracture, a 2023 right index finger fracture that was his only IR stint, 2024 plantar fasciitis, and a 2025 Week 13 left-hand fracture that needed a plate and screws yet still let him start Week 14. The recurring theme is throwing-side finger trauma plus accumulating damage to the non-throwing hand, and the QB room behind him is Trey Lance and nobody, so a real absence is a roster-wide problem.

Draft at the QB9 turn if the August camp report has both Slater and Alt on the field; if either tackle is still limited, let him slide and take the next quick-game QB with a cleaner line.

Want analysis like this for every player on your board?

Try YAC free